Why a CV Isn’t the Same as Candidate Fit
- Michelle Denny
- Jul 27
- 3 min read
Part of our 'How to Hire Better' series for HR leaders and hiring managers
When a CV lands on your desk that ticks all the boxes, experience, skills, qualifications, it’s easy to think, “This is the one.” But a strong CV doesn’t always equal a strong hire.
At Michelle Denny Recruitment Consultancy, we’ve seen time and again how businesses come unstuck by hiring solely on paper. Why? Because fit, real fit, lives and shows up in the spaces a CV can’t capture.

In this blog, we’re digging into what “fit” actually means, why it’s crucial to get right, and how to avoid costly mis-hires that cost time, money and morale.
Let’s define ‘fit’, properly
Fit isn’t about who you’d want to have a drink with. It’s about alignment. Between your expectations and the candidate’s behaviours. Between what the job really needs and how the person operates when the pressure’s on. It’s the blend of competence, communication style, pace, values, flexibility, and whether those things slot into your culture, team dynamic and strategic direction.
CVs tell you where someone’s been. Fit tells you whether they’ll thrive where you’re going.
What you miss when you rely on the CV alone
A CV is, by design, a sales document. It shows what the candidate wants you to see. It rarely shows:
How they behave under pressure
Whether they collaborate well (or prefer solo work)
How they lead, or follow
How they learn, take feedback, handle ambiguity
Whether they’ll challenge ideas productively, or push back disruptively
These are often the reasons someone stays or goes. Thrives or folds. Elevates a team or causes weeks of recovery work.
The risk of getting it wrong
A mis-hire is more than just a regret. It’s expensive.
The CIPD estimates the cost of a failed hire at senior level is well into five figures. But it’s the hidden costs that sting:
Weeks of onboarding that don’t go anywhere
Drop in morale and engagement from the team
Project or client delays
Damage to internal trust and decision-making confidence
Having to restart the process, with reputational knock-on
And if you’re a growing business, one misstep can seriously slow your momentum.
What we do differently at MDR Consultancy
We’re not in the business of “get ‘em in, send ‘em over” recruitment. As we always say, we are no a CV sausage machine. Our consultancy-led process is designed to uncover fit, not just find a match.
Here’s how we approach it:
Behavioural Role Analysis:
We dig into the actual needs of the role, beyond the job spec. That includes behaviours, dynamics, and success measures.
Role-Specific Psychometrics:
For strategic or business-critical hires, we offer a Role Survey that helps map the ideal profile and assess candidates objectively against it.
In-depth Discovery:
We spend time with both you and the candidate. Not just to verify capability, but to test alignment, expectations, pace, leadership, mindset.
Video and Scenario Assessments:
Where appropriate, we give you more than words on a page. You see the person in action, how they think, how they communicate, how they handle challenge.
The result? You’re not guessing. You’re hiring with clarity and confidence.
Why this matters for your business
Well, hiring is a risk. It always will be.
But you can reduce that risk significantly with a process that goes deeper than the CV. A process that helps you see, not just read, the people you’re choosing from.
When you work with MDRC, you’re getting more than candidates. You’re getting consultancy, challenge, and an honest lens on what will (and won’t) work. That’s what makes the difference.
Not sure where to start?
We’re always up for a coffee and a conversation. No pressure, just honest advice.
📩 Or drop us a message if you're hiring now or planning ahead.





Comments